Why Palestine is right? : why Israel has no right to exist.
Index:
Basic Story
Is Israel a "settler-colony"?
Is Gaza a concentration camp?
Are Israelis just refugees from the Holocaust?
Did the Zionists steal Palestinian Land and properties?
Is this a conflict between Jews and Muslims?
Is this a conflict between Jews and Muslims?
Israel is a US puppet?
What about Hamas? Isn't it just terrorists? They kill innocents?
Is Israel an apartheid state?
Did the Palestinians leave in 1947 so that Arab nations could wipe out Israel?
Do Palestinians don't want "any" solution except the annihilation of Israel?
Did the Arabs start the 6 day war to annihilate Israel because they hated them?
Did Palestine exist? in 1900s?
Did Israel exist, in 1919?
Is there a future to this? Whose responsibility?
Basic Story:
Palestinians Muslims, Jews, Christians were living happily in Palestine.
Then a bunch of Ashkenazi Jews (Zionists) from Europe came into Israel with a specific plan. The plan was to wipe out the Palestinians and create their own ethnostate.
These Zionists started building settlements there, then started to kill and drive away the Palestinians. The zionists had influence in British and US governments, so they used them and other International Organizations like the UN to "give" a large chunk of Palestine to themselves.
The Palestinians and neiboring Arab countries didn't like this colonization of their land, so they fought many times. But Israel had better technically educated population (because they are European settlers) and support of Britain/US, so they won each time.
After this, they put the remaining Palestinians into a concentration camp called Gaza and a more open prison called West Bank.
After all this, the Zionists use heavy media PR campaign to paint themselves as the victims. They hide their colonization of Palestine by telling everybody that this is a "land dispute"/"Israel-Palestine conflict"/etc... They tell everybody that the Palestinians are scary Muslims who are savages and "terrorists".
Watch this video for more detail - Noam Chomsky "The Occupation of Palestine: A Short History"
Hence we can see why "Israel" is a fake country and has no right to exist. It will fade away into the dustheap of history just like Apartheid South Africa, slavery in United States, etc..
Is Israel a "settler-colony"?
Yes. Zionists from around the world come to experience their colonial fantasy in historic Palestine. Most of the "citizens" of Israel are either "not born there"/"their parents were not born there". This video goes in detail about this - Israelis Are Not 'Indigenous'
Do the Palestinian fighters use civilians as human shields?
The Amnesty International human rights organisation has found out no evidence of Palestinian fighters using human shields. It has however found evidence of Israel using civilians as human shield, in violation of International law. It has also found evidence that Israel deliberately targets civilians and uses weapons which are deadly to civilians. Amnesty Report
Is Gaza a concentration camp?
Geneology of the word "concentration camp" dates back to the Boer war when they rounded up their "enemy" population into designated areas controlled by them, to be removed.
Gaza fits this. It is walled in from all sides. Food, Electricity and water are all controlled by the Israeli military. Nobody can go in or out of the city without the permission of the Israeli military. Palestinians are killed or humiliated daily.
According to leaked documents, In 2004, Israel’s own National Security Director Giora Eiland said that Gaza is a “huge concentration camp.” - Wikileaks
Are Israelis just refugees from the Holocaust?
While anti-semitic persecution in Europe did play some part in the settlement of some Jews into Palestine, it is not at all true that they are just refugees. Most refugees preferred to go to developed countries like the US. The Zionist movement with the backing of the British Government carried out a planned settler colonial movement in which the Palestinians were wiped out and Jews from any part of the world were given incentives of money and stolen land to settle in Palestine. This is continuing to this very day, by the illegal settlements in the West Bank and the expulsion of Palestinians from Jerusalem. This video has more details - Israelis Are Not 'Indigenous'
Is this a conflict between Jews and Muslims?
Not at all. It is a conflict between the colonizers and the indigenous people (the palestinians). There are Palestinians Jews as well as Chrisitians. In 1900 Christians were 11% of the population, but now due to Israeli occupation there are only less than 2% Christians left in Israel/Palestine. Israeli military government is stealing the land of Palestinian Christians. Watch this video ;
Did the Zionists steal Palestinian Land and properties?
Yes. They planned it.
"The Zionist authorities immediately allocated ethnically cleansed Palestinian houses, schools and libraries to host the Jewish refugees coming from Europe."[i]
"Everything was planned for. They planned their thefts and planned to legitimise these thefts."[i]
"Even those Palestinians who fled 1km to a nearby village, due to violence, was/is not allowed to return to their homes."[i]
Israel is a US puppet?
Israel bombs Lebanon, Syria and Iran on behalf of US interests. US stores its weapons in Israel for its attack on Arab countries. Israel receives millions of dollars and weapons every year due to this. It also gets US support in the UN for its war crimes due to this symbiotic relationship.
What about Hamas? Isn't it just terrorists? They kill innocents?
Hamas is a right wing National Liberation organization of Palestinians. So far, they have made it clear in their statements that they believe it is their duty as Muslims to NOT harm children, elderly, women, etc.. Most military operations such as the October 7, 2023 Al Aqsa flood operation are jointly conducted along with the Communist/Leftist organizations such as PFLP, DFLP, etc.. Hamas enjoy wide support from the people of Gaza. Hamas in its operations as an agent of National Liberation should be suported. Remember it is always "right to rebel".
Is Israel an apartheid state?
Yes. Israel has seperate laws for Jews and Arabs by race. No other modern state on earth has such racist practices. Arabs are treated as second class citizens by law in the Israeli constitution. Read more in detail here.
Did the Palestinians leave in 1947 so that Arab nations could wipe out Israel?
Absolutely not. If you read about Plan Dalet, you will know that the Israeli leaders planned militarily to attack and ethnically cleanse Palestinian villages through violence, and it is this forced, violent terrorism that led to the expulsion of Palestinians.
Plan Dalet: "each brigade commander received a list of the villages or neighborhoods that had to be occupied, destroyed, and their inhabitants expelled"[i]
"400 and 600 Palestinian villages were destroyed, village wells were poisoned in a biological warfare programme and properties were looted to prevent Palestinian refugees from returning,"[i]
Do Palestinians don't want "any" solution except the annihilation of Israel?
This too is a zionist lie. The truth is that, with the help of US support, and apathy of the International community, Israel has been expanding forever into UN designated Palestinian areas. It is the opinion of British politicians who visited Gaza, Hamas, etc.. that the Palestinians are very much willing to get the 2 state solution even, but unfortunately with the full support of the western world, Israel only wants to get rid of the Palestinians. It is by all means Israel who don't want a peaceful solution. Israel has opposed any means to a two-state solution.
Did the Arabs start the 6 day war to annihilate Israel because they hated them?
Nope. Israel provoked this war, the Arabs had no choice. Also, the arabs had a very sub-par (almost powerless) military despite having some advanced weapons. Learn more from this video.
Egypt sent its military into the Sinai (not to Israel), to prevent Israel's invasion of Syria. Egypt was unable to attack Israel first because the US threatened them. So, contrary to popular myths, Israel was the only country more prepared for this "surprise" war.
Did Palestine exist? in 1900s?
Yes. It had a sizeable arab (muslim, christian and jew) population. Jerusalem city exported goods to Europe and North Africa. This documentary by Al Jazeera goes into detail about this. It had railways (1892-), ports, factories (11 floor tile factories, metal casting company - The Palestinian Sakeb Company), music bands, cinema halls, schools, orphanages, international boxing championships, political party, independence movement ...
People used to come from all over the middle east to work in Jaffa (city in Palestine), despite British limiting the inflow of arab workers.
Did Israel exist, in 1919?
Azhkenazi Jews were a tiny minority.
"From 1882 until 1919, the number of Jews in Jaffa and north-east Jaffa was only 2000"[i]
Is there a future to this? Whose responsibility?
Responsibility is with the only group which has any power in the region, which is Israel. If Israel wanted to,
1. it would create a one state confederation with equal rights to all citizens, arab or israeli
2. it would eliminate the "automatic citizenship" to any jew on the planet
3. it would make peace with its arab neibors instead of being a US puppet
4. it would atleast pay the Palestinians compensation for the land and homes they stole during the Nakba and other ethnic cleansings.
5. it would eliminate the idea of an ethnostate i.e. "jewish homeland"
6. it would stop the settlements in the west bank and other palestinian territories
7. it would invite arab-israeli mixed leadership to oversee issues in Jerusalem
Some utterly garbage arguments
Israel is the homeland of the Jews?
I hope you (the one making this argument) get hit by a Palestinian Rocket and die.
Jews are smart. They have lot of Nobel Prizes. So they can do what they want
I hope you (the one making this argument) get killed by an IED (land mine).
Muslims are barbaric. They don't deserve right to homeland. They will create horrible dictatorship
The communists are coming to get you, you fascist scum.
Comments
Post a Comment